DOWLING FAMILY PARTNERSHIP, a South Dakota General Partnership and DOWLING BROTHERS PARTNERSHIP, a South Dakota General Partnership, Plaintiffs and Appellees,
MIDLAND FARMS, LLC, an Iowa Limited Liability Company; Defendant and Appellant. and LANNY DEMOTT, Defendant
Argued February 17, 2015
[Copyrighted Material Omitted]
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SIXTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT HAAKON COUNTY, SOUTH DAKOTA. THE HONORABLE PATRICIA DEVANEY, Judge.
GREGORY A. EIESLAND of Johnson Eiesland Law Offices, PC, Rapid City, South Dakota; THOMAS P. MAHER, THOMAS M. MAHER of Maher Law Office, LLP, Pierre, South Dakota, Attorneys for plaintiffs and appellees.
WILLIAM G. TAYLOR, JAMES E. MOORE of Woods, Fuller, Shultz & Smith PC, Sioux Falls, South Dakota, Attorneys for defendant and appellant.
SEVERSON, Justice. GILBERTSON, Chief Justice, and ZINTER, Justice, and SPEARS and CUTLER, Circuit Court Judges, concur. SPEARS, Circuit Court Judge, sitting for WILBUR, Justice, disqualified. CUTLER, Circuit Court Judge, sitting for KERN, Justice, disqualified.
[¶1] Midland Farms, LLC, appeals the circuit court's denial of its request for restitution from Dowling Family Partnership and Dowling Brothers Partnership (collectively, " the Partnerships" ). Midland asserts that the Partnerships were unjustly enriched by receiving the proceeds from a winter wheat crop planted at the partial expense of a third party. The Partnerships assert that Midland breached a lease agreement with the Partnerships and should not be granted equitable relief. We affirm.
Facts and Procedural History
[¶2] The Partnerships were formed by brothers Scott Dowling (" Dowling" ) and Tracy Dowling for the purposes of farming and raising livestock. Dowling was the managing partner of the Partnerships at all relevant times. Midland is a limited liability company formed in 2008. It owns approximately 33,000 acres of farmland in Haakon and Stanley Counties, South Dakota. Scott DeMott is a farmer and insurance agent who resides in Little Rock, Arkansas. DeMott was a managing member of Midland at all relevant times.
[¶3] The parties entered into a cash farm lease on May 18, 2009, for approximately 10,276 acres. The lease terminated after the 2009 crop harvest but required Midland, " prior to renting the leased premises for the 2010 crop year, [to] give Tenant a first opportunity to rent the leased premises." In 2010, the parties executed two leases: one crop-share farm lease for approximately 13,384 acres and one cash farm lease for approximately 15,725 acres. Similar to the 2009 lease, the 2010 cash farm lease contained a provision that required Midland to " give Tenant a first opportunity to rent the leased premises" before " renting the leased premises for the 2011 crop year[" On January 19, 2011, Midland and the Partnerships executed a cash farm lease for approximately 29,012 acres at $55 per acre. That lease contained the following provision:
TERM. The term of the cash farm lease for the leased premises shall commence on the day of October, 2010, and shall terminate after the 2012 crop harvest, unless otherwise extended, terminated,
or provided for herein, except as provided in 8e.
Landlord will give tenant option to rent leased premises for the 2013, 2014 and 2015 crop year. Terms and conditions to be agreed to by Landlord and Tenant.
[¶4] In April 2012, DeMott called Dowling and said, " You have the first right of refusal to rent. Do you want to rent it in the future?" After Dowling indicated he wished to continue leasing the property at the same price, DeMott said, " We gave you your first right of refusal for the lease. We're going to market this because we think we have other--because we have other options to look at." In an email dated July 23, 2012, DeMott further stated:
Also per paragraph 3 Midland Farms has given you the option to lease our farm for 2013, 2014 and 2015 crop years per phone conversation with me at the end of April 2012. You indicated you would rent the farm with the same expiring cash rent of $55 per acre. Midland Farms is not accepting this offer. We have other qualified interested parties willing to lease our farm, if you have any serious interest in renting all or part of Midland Farms, contact us by August 1, 2012.
DeMott and Dowling met in person on July 25, 2012, to discuss terms and conditions of a potential lease for 2013, 2014, and 2015. DeMott told Dowling that Midland required a lease price of $70 per acre and an irrevocable letter of credit for the full amount " ASAP" to secure the rent payment for the 2013 crop year. Dowling's banker approved the new lease for the 2013, 2014, and 2015 crop years at the agreed upon price of $70 per acre and testified that the bank would have approved a formal irrevocable letter of credit if the bank had been provided with the final written lease documents.
[¶5] Dowling called DeMott on August 1, 2012, and accepted the offer. Thereafter, Dowling entered into a contract to purchase a new sprayer for $324,000 and began harrowing the Midland property in August at a cost of $46,000. Five days after Dowling agreed to DeMott's terms, on August 6, DeMott emailed Dowling and asked, " What name do I use for you on our farm lease?"  However, only two days later, DeMott called Dowling and told him that Midland had sold the farm to a third party, Clement Farms. The following day, on August 9, Dowling answered DeMott's August 6 inquiry and provided the tenant name for the lease. No new written lease agreement was formally drafted for the 2013, 2014, or 2015 crop years. Instead, on August 13, 2012, DeMott emailed Dowling to inform him that Midland was seeking a legal determination in circuit court that the parties had not extended the prior lease and warning him to cease farming operations on Midland property.
[¶6] Midland served a notice to quit and vacate the property on the Partnerships on August 20, 2012. The Partnerships filed a complaint for a declaratory judgment and other relief on September 7, 2012. The circuit court consolidated these two actions on October 30, 2012. In the meantime, Midland entered into a lease agreement with Clement on September ...